The pattern beneath
Why do people leave hate comments?
People leave hate comments because a post has touched something in their life they don't want to look at, and a stranger is the safest place to aim what that stirs up. It mostly happens at the end of a day full of yeses they didn't mean, with nobody watching and nothing to lose. The words land on you, but they were meant for someone else.
The full episode, with the three questions I ask before replying to anyone online, is Episode 550 of The Architect Speaks.
Have you ever posted something ordinary and come back to find a stranger telling you, at length, that you've got your own life wrong? Or have you caught yourself late at night with a reply half-written to someone you'll never meet, and wondered why you care this much?
A little while ago a man I'd never met told me, under one of my videos, that I have no say in my own life. The universe runs the entire show, he said: a heart attack, an accident, a lottery win. I hadn't said a word about any of those. The video asked whether you've ever looked at your life and chosen to keep walking it. Why would a man watch a video about choosing and feel he has to tell a stranger that choosing isn't real? That's the question behind Episode 550 of The Architect Speaks.
What are people really arguing with in the comments?
I started this work in May 2006, and I've sat with thousands of men and women since.
And what you learn in a room like that, across from so many people, across so many different contexts, hour after hour, is that people don't argue with what you said. They argue instead with what it touched.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 550
The comments section is where you see that most clearly, because it's the one place people argue with nothing at stake. Think about where they are when they write. They're on the toilet with the door locked, in the only five minutes nobody can reach them. They're on the couch at eleven at night, or in a car park on their lunch break, eating a homemade sandwich over the steering wheel.
They're tired from a day of small betrayals of themselves, which I call incoherent sacrifices: the yes they didn't mean, the meeting they agreed their way through. Then a stranger's video says something true about their life, and all of that goes into the reply.
Say you're in your early fifties, managing a boss twenty years younger who talks to you as if you're slow. You've said “no problem” six times today, and it was a problem every time. Late that night a stranger online says people who never consciously choose their life end up feeling like visitors in their own house. You know it's you. So you type, “You have no idea that the universe runs the show, do you?” and you feel better for about a minute.
Or say the children are finally asleep, you've cleaned the kitchen and nobody thanked you, and you've sat down for the first time since six in the morning. A man on a video says people who can't rest until everyone in the house has been fed are running something they never chose. So you write, “Easy for you to say across the other side of the world when you don't have three kids and a job.” Then you go to bed with your heart racing, because something in you recognised something in what he said.
Why do people argue with strangers online?
Because a stranger is the safest target there is. You can't speak like that to your wife, because you have to sleep next to her tonight, or to your boss, because you need the job. Your mother would go quiet for a fortnight. Your husband is someone you rely on. A stranger comes with no relationship to lose and no Sunday lunch to sit through afterwards, and if it goes badly you can delete the comment.
So the comments section collects everything people can't say anywhere else. And it gets aimed at whoever said the thing that touched it.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 550
If you're on the receiving end of a comment like that, start there. It reached you because you said the thing that touched it. The person it was really meant for is at home, or at work, and can't be told.
Why do people leave rude comments that miss the point?
A handful of comments turn up again and again. One is “easy for you to say, you don't know my life”. That's true, I don't. What it usually means is: please don't make me look. A comment like that is a door being shut. Another is the one-word fight. I said “most”, and someone found the exception. I said “chose”, and someone wrote four paragraphs on the meaning of choice. That's the pattern finding the smallest place to stand, so it doesn't have to stand on the big thing.
Then there's the essay at one in the morning, very long and very angry, every argument numbered.
The length tells you how much it touched somebody's wound. Nobody writes 900 words in the comments section of a Facebook post at one o'clock in the morning to a stranger about something that didn't touch them.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 550
The one I see most hands your life over to something else: the universe decides, everything happens for a reason. I've no problem with anyone's beliefs, but this one never turns up under a video about cats. It turns up under a video about choosing your life, because if something bigger is running the show, there's nothing for you to look at. Hand over the outcomes of your life, and your responsibility and your agency go with them. The man under my video went on to say that we co-create with the universe, of which we are an equal part. If you're an equal part of what's doing the creating, the part that chooses is you. He made my point, then argued with it.
Why do arguments online affect me so much?
I'm not above any of this.
Some nights I read a comment and I feel the old pull to win, to win the battle, to have the last word, to write my own essay at one in the morning as well.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 550
When I notice that, I ask what I'd ask anyone else: what did that comment touch in me? Usually it's the old voice that says I'm only worth something if I'm right, the one behind needing to be right to feel worthy. If a stranger's comment is still with you hours later, that question will tell you more than anything the stranger wrote.
It's also why I almost never concede in the comments. When a pattern is running that hot, agreeing with it feeds it. If a man on his couch at eleven at night says the universe runs the show and I agree, he goes to bed a little more sure that nothing he does matters. I made that move for years, softening what was true to keep the peace. That was one of my own incoherent sacrifices.
A coherent comment is different. It asks a real question. It owns something: this is where I am, and this is the part I'm not sure about. It disagrees with what I actually said, rather than with what I touched, and if it's right, I say so. If a comment has stung you, put it to the same test.
What should you ask yourself before replying to a comment?
Before you reply to a stranger, ask yourself three questions.
- What time is it? If it's late at night, or your lunch break, or you're sitting in the car outside your own house because you can't face going in, that's information.
- What happened today? Who did you say yes to when you meant no? How many times did you betray yourself before you picked up the phone?
- Who do you actually want to say this to? It might be your husband or your wife, your boss, your mother, a father who's been dead for eleven years, or yourself, out loud.
If you still want to write the comment, write it in the notes on your phone instead of the reply box. Put that person's name at the top, read it back the next morning, and I think you'll find it was never about the post.
The comments section is a record of everything people can't say to the people who matter in their lives, aimed at the people who don't. This week, before you reply to anyone you've never met, look at the clock.
The Atlas names the pattern running your life, including the one that picks your fights for you, from your own words in a single sitting. Begin the Atlas.
Questions people ask
Why do people leave rude comments on YouTube?
Look at when they're written. Most arrive late in the evening, or on a lunch break, after a day spent agreeing to things the writer didn't want. They land under whichever video said something true about the writer's life. A creator on YouTube is a stranger, and a stranger is the one person you can be rude to without anything at home changing.
Should you reply to a hate comment?
Agreeing with it rarely helps the person who wrote it. When a pattern is running that hot, a stranger's agreement only feeds it and leaves the writer a little more stuck. I almost never concede in the comments for that reason. A comment that asks a real question and disagrees with what you actually said is different: think about it, and if the writer is right, say so.
Why does arguing with strangers online feel good at the time?
Because for about a minute, something that has been building all day finally goes somewhere. The relief doesn't last, because it went to the wrong person. The husband, the wife, the boss or the parent it belonged to hasn't heard a word of it, so it's all still there tomorrow. What's left is to say it, one honest sentence at a time, to whoever it was really meant for.
The Atlas names the pattern running your life in a single sitting. It is built from twenty years in the chair and the thirty-three books of Michael Lauria, a qualified therapist, author and philosophical mythologist. It takes about forty-five minutes, costs nothing, and ends in a written Record of that pattern, drawn from your own words. It is not therapy and not for crisis. Begin the Atlas · How the Atlas works
Or begin smaller with the nine-question pattern test, about three minutes, no sign-up.
Listen to the episode
- Why Strangers Argue in the Comments (Episode 550) on The Architect Speaks
- Watch it on YouTube