Learn at your own pace, free: tests, courses and guides in THE CODEX →
Codex of the ArchitectMichael Lauria

The pattern beneath

Why do people pleasers get angry?

By , qualified therapist, author and philosophical mythologist. Twenty years in private practice. Updated . Enter the Atlas (free)

People pleasers get angry because the anger they never let into the room doesn't disappear. Every time they say it's fine when it isn't, something gets stored. Their niceness also comes with a silent arrangement that only they signed up to. When others fail to notice what was never said, the stored anger gets out, usually on whoever is closest.

I talk this through in full in Episode 548 of The Architect Speaks.

Have you ever been the person everyone rings when something goes wrong, the calm one, the reasonable one? And have you then heard yourself say something sharp to someone who'd done nothing at all? Have you noticed it's almost never the person who upset you who gets it?

For twenty years the nicest men and women who sat across from me were usually the angriest people in their lives. Most had hidden it so well they no longer knew it was there. I talk about two of them in Episode 548.

Are people pleasers secretly angry?

The first was a man I worked with for about three years, the most reasonable person you could hope to meet. He could name the exact moment in childhood when he decided his anger wasn't safe to show. Then his wife told him she'd been unfaithful for months and had fallen in love with the other man. The next day he described it to me in the same measured voice he used for everything. When I asked what he felt, he gave me one word: disappointed. Everything stronger had been sent away when he was a boy.

The second was a woman everybody rang: her sister, her mother, her friends late at night. She picked up every time. When I asked what she wanted for herself, she said she was too busy to think about it. Then something came out almost in passing.

She told me she started to feel glimmers of contempt for the people that she was helping. And she was frightened of the contempt and also the seeds of resentment that were starting to form. Because she'd always thought of herself as a very kind person.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 548

He couldn't feel his anger at all. She could feel hers and was ashamed of it. Both are what anger usually looks like in someone who pleases people.

Why do people pleasers take their anger out on the wrong people?

Men, let's say your manager presents three months of your work as his own, in front of people whose respect you've worked a decade for. You hear yourself say, “Yes, good work.” Afterwards you sit in the driveway with the engine off for twenty minutes. Then your son or daughter asks for help with maths homework, you snap, “Not now,” and your child steps back from you.

Women, let's say it's your first free Sunday in three weeks and your mother rings wanting a lift to the garden centre an hour away. You say, “Of course, Mum,” and when your partner asks what's wrong you say nothing. At dinner he asks you to pass the salt and you hear yourself say, “Can't you do a single thing for yourself?” He looks at you as if he doesn't know who you are, and in that moment neither do you.

When the anger finally gets out, it's expressed badly and out of all proportion to what's in front of you.

It lands on your daughter, on your son, on your husband or wife, on the salt, whoever happens to be closest and whatever happens to be right there. And usually never on the person who caused it in the first place.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 548

Then the shame comes, and the shame becomes one more reason to be even nicer tomorrow. I've written separately about why you take your anger out on the people nearest you.

Where does people pleaser anger come from?

Nobody arrives in the world nice. A child works out, usually before seven or eight, what anger does in that particular house. Men, a lot of you learned it like this. You could tell from the way your father shut the front door what kind of night it was going to be, and you promised yourself you'd never be that man. So you became the calm one, the one who never raises his voice.

The trouble with this is that you didn't only shut off his kind of anger, you shut off all of it, including the part that would let you look another man in the eye and say, No. That was my work and you know it. How dare you take the credit.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 548

Women, many of you learned it differently. You were the child who was needed, the one who sat with your mother while she cried in the kitchen. Whenever you put yourself first, even for an hour, something came back at you: a silence that went on for days, or “Don't worry about me, I'll manage on my own.” So you learned that wanting anything was selfish.

Both children were right, in that house, because children depend completely on the people who look after them. That's how the pattern gets installed. But the deal you struck at seven is still deciding whose call you answer and what you're allowed to want. And every time someone walked over what you wanted, or you walked over it yourself, something in you made a note. For him, it's the job in another town he turned down a decade ago because his wife said it wasn't a good time. For her, it's the friend she drives to the airport at five in the morning, who couldn't come to her father's funeral because it was a busy week. None of it goes anywhere, which is why a row over the salt is never about the salt.

Why do nice people become mean?

Most of what we call niceness comes with an unspoken arrangement that nobody else ever agreed to. A man's version runs something like this: I don't complain, I don't ask for anything, I carry it all and keep the peace, so you should respect me for it. And a woman's: I hold everybody together and put myself last, so you should notice what I need without my having to say it.

Nobody signed up for that. His wife didn't know how he felt about the job, because he told her she was right. So when nobody notices, you feel betrayed by people who never knew there was anything to betray. From the outside it looks like a kind person turning mean for no reason. I've looked at the marriage version of this in why you resent a spouse for not noticing.

In my work I call this an incoherent sacrifice. A coherent one is chosen with your eyes open, for something you actually value, and you don't need anyone to make it up to you afterwards.

An incoherent sacrifice is one you make to avoid a fight, or a confrontation, or an uncomfortable room. And then you hold that against the other person for many, many years. And the so-called nicest people I know are carrying dozens of them.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Episode 548

How do you stop people pleaser anger building up?

Most people try one of two things, and neither works. The first is to get rid of the feeling: one more set at the gym, a third glass of wine on a work night, a bath and a podcast about letting go. The feeling goes quiet for an evening and nothing else changes. The second is to let it all out at once, nine years of it at the Christmas table: “You've never once in thirty years asked me how I am.” Your father leaves the room, and from then on you're the one who ruined Christmas. Everything you said might have been true, and none of it was heard.

What changes things is much smaller. It's one sentence, said to the person it belongs to, at the time it happens, about that one thing and nothing else. For him, it's in the meeting, before the moment passes: “That was my analysis. I'll take the questions from anybody on that.” For her, it's on the phone on Sunday morning: “Mum, I'm sorry, I can't do it today. I can, though, on Wednesday after work.”

Start this week. Catch the first time you hear yourself say “It's fine”, or let something go to keep the peace, when it isn't fine. You don't have to fix it there and then. That night, write down in one line what you actually wanted. The next time the same thing comes round, say that line out loud to the person concerned, while it's still about this one thing.

If you want to see where your own anger went and what sent it there, that's the pattern the Atlas names, from what you tell it, in a single sitting. Begin the Atlas.

Sacrifice: The Pattern Beneath All Patterns by Michael Lauria, cover

Sacrifice: The Pattern Beneath All Patterns

Every choice read as a sacrifice, and every symptom as the cost of sacrificing incoherently. One of the thirty-three books of the Codex of the Architect.

About the book

Questions people ask

Is people pleasing a form of repressed anger?

Very often it is. A child who found out at home that anger was dangerous kept the niceness and sent the anger away. As an adult you say it's fine and believe it at the time. The anger is still there, stored with every request you agreed to without wanting to, and it surfaces later, usually on someone who had nothing to do with it.

Why do people get angry when you stop people pleasing?

Because some of them were comfortable with the old arrangement. When you start saying what you want, some people adjust and carry on as if nothing happened. Others push back, because your silence suited them. How they react shows you how much of the relationship was standing on your self-betrayal, and on a false version of you that you'd been handing them for years.

Why does saying what I want leave me feeling guilty?

Because the guilt is older than the situation. Somewhere before seven or eight, you decided that one honest sentence could lose you everyone, and the guilt is that decision speaking. It tells you nothing about what you've just done. Telling your mother you can't drive her today but can on Wednesday harms nobody. The guilt arrives anyway, and it belongs to the child who made that decision.

The Atlas names the pattern running your life in a single sitting. It is built from twenty years in the chair and the thirty-three books of Michael Lauria, a qualified therapist, author and philosophical mythologist. It takes about forty-five minutes, costs nothing, and ends in a written Record of that pattern, drawn from your own words. It is not therapy and not for crisis. Begin the Atlas · How the Atlas works

Or begin smaller with the nine-question pattern test, about three minutes, no sign-up.

Listen to the episode

Related questions

Michael Lauria is a qualified therapist, author and philosophical mythologist. He has practised since 2006, with more than 25,000 hours in the chair, and is the author of Obsolete and Twenty Years in the Chair.