Learn at your own pace, free: tests, courses and guides in THE CODEX →
Codex of the ArchitectMichael Lauria

The pattern beneath

What is Iron John about?

By , qualified therapist, author and philosophical mythologist. Twenty years in private practice. Updated . Enter the Atlas (free)

Iron John is Robert Bly's 1990 book about the wound modern men carry: no initiation into manhood, and fathers who were in the house but out of reach. Bly told it through a Grimm fairy tale and the old myths of cultures that understood initiation. It isn't a self-help book. It's a poet's meditation on the masculine wound, and that is both its gift and its limit.

I talk through the book and the men's work it inspired in Episode 3 of my Men's Work series on The Architect Speaks.

Iron John inspired a whole tradition of men's circles, so I'll start with a weekend inside one. I'd been invited to men's retreats many times before I went. I declined each time, not only from arrogance, but because I'd watched the men who went to these gatherings and formed a clinical impression of what I'd find inside them, and the impression wasn't entirely generous. Then someone challenged me publicly. I had called men's circles perpetual circles of pain, and a man replied, "If you've never sat in circle, what authority do you speak from?" It was a fair point, so the next time I was invited, I went. I describe that weekend in Episode 3 of my Men's Work series, because it shows what the book gives men and where it leaves them.

Who was Robert Bly?

Robert Bly wasn't a psychologist or a therapist, and he made no claim to clinical authority. He was a poet, Harvard educated, who won the National Book Award in 1968 and was one of the most significant American poets of the twentieth century. He opposed the Vietnam War publicly, at personal cost, when doing so wasn't safe. He lived on a farm in Minnesota and wrote with the authority of a man who had done the work of solitude. Iron John was published in 1990 and spent 62 weeks on the New York Times bestseller list. His credential was life, the most honest credential of any author I covered in my Men's Work series, and also the reason the book stops where it does.

What is Iron John about?

It's a poet's meditation on the masculine wound, delivered through a Grimm fairy tale and the gathered mythologies of cultures that understood initiation in ways the modern West had long forgotten. Bly saw things that were true. He saw that modern life had severed men from something essential, and that the absence of initiation had left a whole generation of men unfinished, boys in adult bodies. He saw the chain of uninitiated men passing their uninitiation down through the generations.

He saw the father wound with extraordinary precision. Not just the absent father, but the father who was physically present and emotionally unreachable.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Men's Work, Episode 3

Above all, he gave men permission to grieve. For many men it was the first permission they'd ever received. He named the wild man, the darkness and the descent a boy must make to become a man, and he named them with more beauty and accuracy than any other men's work author I looked at.

What happens at a men's retreat?

When the men arrived that weekend, the hugs were real and so was the laughter. These men love each other, and the community isn't performed. What I understood the next morning was that the warmth was also relief. For those two days the performance could be set down, and the grief and the father wound had somewhere to go, other men who would witness them without flinching. That evening, around the fire, the first man breathed visibly, spoke, and within seconds the tears were there. Every man did the same.

What I watched those men do at the fire was wipe the blood away from the wound very carefully, very gently with genuine love for each other, whilst also very carefully and gently and lovingly avoiding any attempt to close the wound.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Men's Work, Episode 3

The difference between the newer men and the ones who'd been coming for years was visible. The newer men's grief came with hesitation and something raw underneath it. The experienced men showed them by example how to breathe before speaking and how to let the tears come. What they demonstrated was grief performed with extraordinary fluency. The wound underneath was real, but the expression had become rehearsed, the tears available within seconds at the fire because the setting had trained the body to produce them there. The man who could open most completely became the one the circle looked to, so the tradition had built a hierarchy of grief, with the men who had performed it longest at the top.

Where does Iron John fall short?

A man can learn to express his wound with more and more fluency and carry it, unclosed, for the rest of his life, because expression releases the pressure without touching the structure that keeps producing it. The wound bleeds at the fire, stops for a few hours, and then he goes home, the pressure builds, and he comes back next week to bleed again. When a man opens his grief in front of men who receive it without flinching, he settles and the isolation lifts for a while. That part is real. Feeling less alone with your wound is a different thing from closing it.

A circle that provides relief without resolution will always require the next circle.Michael Lauria, The Architect Speaks, Men's Work, Episode 3

This is the failure of a poet rather than a surgeon. Bly described the forest. He stood at its edge and described what was inside with extraordinary beauty, and then he stayed at the edge. The book points at the entrance, describes what the descent requires, and leaves the man to make it alone, with a drum and with other men who haven't been into the forest either. A poet names the territory and a surgeon operates on it. Bly never claimed to have surgical tools.

Is Iron John worth reading?

I'm not saying Bly was wrong to write it, or that permission to grieve is a mistake. Some of it is truly valuable, and for many men the Bly tradition was the first place they met other men willing to be honestly wounded in front of each other. What I am saying is that the men inside it deserved more than it could give. The grief was the beginning of the work, not the work itself. Iron John is the most beautiful map to the entrance of the forest that has been written, and a map can't take you in.

If you've been in these circles for years and know, somewhere, that they aren't moving you: the grief is real and so is the brotherhood. What you found there was always meant to prepare you for the descent. The forest is still there, and the entrance is still where Bly pointed. I've also answered whether men's work actually works, and why so many men don't talk about their feelings in the first place.

If you've been standing at the entrance for years, the Atlas names the pattern running your life from your own words, in a single sitting. Begin the Atlas.

The Descent of the Hero by Michael Lauria, cover

The Descent of the Hero

The old blueprint of strength and provision was burned and nothing replaced it. Why the descent is not the end but part of the way through. One of the thirty-three books of the Codex of the Architect.

About the book

Questions people ask

Is Iron John a self-help book?

No. It's a poet's meditation on the masculine wound, told through a Grimm fairy tale and old myths of initiation. Robert Bly was a poet who won the National Book Award, and he never claimed clinical authority. His gift was naming the wound, and he named it with more beauty and accuracy than any other men's work author I looked at.

Who wrote Iron John, and when?

Robert Bly, the American poet, published Iron John in 1990, and it spent 62 weeks on the New York Times bestseller list. Bly was Harvard educated, won the National Book Award in 1968, opposed the Vietnam War publicly and lived on a farm in Minnesota.

Do men's circles work?

They give real relief. A man who opens his grief in front of men who don't flinch settles, and the isolation lifts for a while. But relief without resolution always requires the next circle. The grief is the beginning of the work, and a tradition built around opening wounds without the tools to close them produces men who are fluent in loss and stationary in their lives.

The Atlas names the pattern running your life in a single sitting. It is built from twenty years in the chair and the thirty-three books of Michael Lauria, a qualified therapist, author and philosophical mythologist. It takes about forty-five minutes, costs nothing, and ends in a written Record of that pattern, drawn from your own words. It is not therapy and not for crisis. Begin the Atlas · How the Atlas works

Or begin smaller with the nine-question pattern test, about three minutes, no sign-up.

Listen to the episode

Related questions

Michael Lauria is a qualified therapist, author and philosophical mythologist. He has practised since 2006, with more than 25,000 hours in the chair, and is the author of Obsolete and Twenty Years in the Chair.